Showing posts with label decision making. Show all posts
Showing posts with label decision making. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

No Award Required

By Rick Van Arnam

On May 19 of this year I stood in the same spot as I did in 1984 – in a living room of what was once a fraternity house and is now home to the admission office for Norwich University.  It was a perfect setting then and remains so now, graced with dark wood paneling, a large fireplace, and oil paintings of the campus in earlier days.

In 1984 I accepted my Regular Army commission as a Second Lieutenant, becoming a naïve infantry officer totally incapable of mapping out the career I was saying goodbye to thirty years later as a far less naïve Colonel.  Like many things in the Army, this was a mandatory event.  I was told that I had to have a retirement ceremony.  Unlike many of those mandatory events, though, I looked forward to this one. I planned it on my terms inviting close friends to join me as I shared final words upon which I had thought for months.  After that, we would head to another dark paneled room locally known as an Irish pub where we would tell some stories, close the bar, and close out my career. 

The Army has retirement ceremonies for many reasons, all of which are good.  People come to celebrate a career and the retiring soldier has one final opportunity to thank those with whom he or she has served.  There is usually food and beer involved so, let’s be honest, that will always attract a few more stragglers to the event.  The most important reason, though, is that it is simply the right thing to do.  But what I hate about the ceremony is the obligatory end-of-service award.

There was a day when awards meant something to me, but that day has long passed.  I remember as a Second Lieutenant being awarded the Army Achievement Medal for being on a team that finished first in a 20k race.  I thought the trophy was recognition enough but someone believed it deserved an award.  Later as a Captain, I was given another award for writing a daily newsletter for two weeks while deployed to Honduras.  Each day I watched CNN Headline News several times in a row on the only television available on the compound.  I furiously took notes and turned those into a one-page newsletter that was distributed to our Special Forces Soldiers in who-knows-where locations not far from the Honduran-Nicaraguan border.  I guess they liked getting the news.  I thought I was simply doing my job, but someone believed it deserved an award.

Throughout history soldiers have served with few expectations for recognition.  This was true back even before our founding fathers wrote, “All men are created equal.” On April 19, 1775, ordinary farmers, blacksmiths and merchants took up arms to defend their belief that, “We had always been free, and were meant to always be free.” [i] Citizen-soldiery was born on this belief and that belief became a promise fulfilled – a promise that their children and grandchildren would have more opportunity than from where they had come.[ii]  Taking up arms was never done on the expectation of receiving an award.

Neither was that the expectation when a bit less than a hundred years later this promise of freedom was put to the ultimate test during the Civil War.  Citizens-soldiers like Joshua Chamberlain once again stood, not by plan or by desire, at history’s pivotal hour.  His simple, one-word command of “Bayonets” on the afternoon of July 2, 1863 helped to forever secure our States as United.

And less than one hundred years after Gettysburg soldiers participated in battles ranging in size from the largest the world had ever witnessed to the smallest – the latter of which Rick Atkinson, author of the Liberation Trilogy termed a “nameless skirmish.”  Soldiers died in both and without the expectation, or care, of receiving an award.  Their ultimate sacrifice is why the end-of-service award is such an awkward moment to me. 

Pinned in my mind and more important than any award pinned to my uniform is one final unanswered question and that is this.  Had I faced real danger, I don’t know if I would have measured up.  How does anyone know, really?

When I was young and very naïve I boasted about wanting to face that danger.  I know I felt that way the morning Rangers jumped into Grenada during the fall of my senior year of college.  The year was 1983 and I was twenty-one years old. 

Truthfully, and despite a lot of training, I really don’t know how I would have performed under similar circumstances.  I don’t know if I would have reacted fast enough had I been caught in a complex ambush in Afghanistan or come face-to-face with an insurgent who had spent most of his life fighting.  Any success I achieved in the Army wasn’t because I was an elite fighter; it was because I simply worked hard.  I probably spent the first few years of my career wanting to know the answer to that question and the years since 9/11 growing comfortable in leaving the question unanswered. 

And through this processing is my real end-of-service award – that simply having the opportunity to serve is award enough.



[i] Nathanial Philbrook, Bunker Hill.
[ii] Nathanial Philbrook, Bunker Hill.

Saturday, March 17, 2012

All The Difference

By Rick Van Arnam


Two roads diverged in a wood, and I –

I took the one less traveled by,

And that has made all the difference.

The Road Not Taken | By Robert Frost


I love this poem. I love the concept of taking a path that most don’t. There is something intuitive in recognizing that a road less traveled by may be richer in some way. Perhaps it is a view - or perspective gained – that would not otherwise be revealed if we simply followed the mainstream in thought or action. More likely the road less traveled becomes an experience that shapes a person in some way. As Robert Frost implies, the experience makes “all the difference” and I think he meant that in a positive way. What is not as intuitive is actually deciding to take the uncommon path – it may appear risky, full of uncertainty or require more work.

A lot of decisions that positively shape character in people require challenging choices. I don’t mean necessarily that the decision is challenging to make, but all that follows after the right decision has been made is challenging. Back in the fall of 1928, John Wooden enrolled at Purdue University where he, “hoped to be good enough to play basketball and smart enough to get my degree.” Athletic scholarships did not exist as they do today, but he was promised a job by the legendary coach ‘Piggie’ Lambert as a means to pay his way through school, a principle in which Coach Lambert believed. During Wooden’s sophomore year a local doctor offered to pay all of John’s college fees. As Wooden tells the story in his book, They Call Me Coach, Coach Lambert extended the offer to Wooden on behalf of the doctor and reminded him of his principle that working oneself through college would make one better appreciate the value of the education. The decision was Wooden’s alone and he declined the offer with full support of his coach. His choice surely made Wooden’s student-athlete-employee role more challenging and explains the lowest-left block in John Wooden’s Pyramid of Success. His famous pyramid is a visual strategy for success that he designed during the mid-to-late 1930’s and shared generously over the remaining sixty-plus years of his life. He defines this block, labeled INDUSTRIOUSNESS, by writing, “There is no substitute for hard work. Worthwhile things come from hard work and careful planning.” There is a reason it is the lower left block of the pyramid; it is the cornerstone. Wooden, like Frost in his musing, recognized that hard work and careful planning, like taking the path less traveled by, make all the difference.

Are there any cautions that come with the road less traveled? Maybe. I think it is wise to be aware of its side trails that are traveled even less. The farther you veer off course, even an uncommon course, the more alone you may find yourself. Without teammates of support that go by the names of Encouragement, Wisdom and Camaraderie, the going may shift from challenging to futile. Even less traveled paths could be dead ends with haunting names like Stubbornness Trail, Unforgiving Road or Prideful Street.

RVA

The Call Me Coach, By John Wooden with Jack Tobin, McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., Copyright 2004

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

A Shoe Story

By Rick Van Arnam

Northfield, Vermont

Who among us has not had a great customer experience about which you can’t wait to tell somebody? Perhaps one indicator of a well-led company is when ordinary customers become de-facto sales representatives who wouldn’t buy from anyone else while encouraging their friends to do the same. That is how I feel about Allen Edmunds - a shoe company.

It took me a long time to buy a pair of Allen Edmunds. The first time I recall trying on a pair of their shoes occurred during an anniversary trip to Chicago back in the mid-1990’s. Connie and I were shopping on Michigan Avenue and we perused our first Allen Edmunds store. At that time, I was working for CompuServe in Columbus, Ohio and was slowly learning how to build a professional wardrobe. I loved their shoes immediately, but could not bring myself to spend nearly $300 on a pair of shoes. It took nearly nine more years and a deployment to Afghanistan before I mustered the financial courage to invest in a new pair of shoes made by Allen Edmunds.

By this time, I had learned that higher end shoe companies offered services to overhaul worn shoes for about the cost of an average pair of new shoes that you might expect to discard after just a couple of years of regular wear. Applying a timeless adage, I had learned that when it comes to shoes, you get what you pay for. A high quality pair of hand-crafted leather shoes will last several years if cared for properly and last perhaps a lifetime with periodic restoration. So one year ago this month, while on my mid-tour leave from Afghanistan, I packaged up my first pair of six-year old Allen Edmunds shoes for shipment to their re-crafting cobblers located in Port Washington, Wisconsin. Packaging was easy – their website has an easy-to-fill-out form with a pre-paid, printable UPS label that I affixed to a box and dropped at a UPS pick-up site. When I returned from Afghanistan six months later, I had a like-new pair of Allen Edmunds shoes waiting for me ready for another six or seven years of use.

Soon after I started to wear these shoes, I received an offer in the mail announcing a special deal on recrafting services. My second pair of Allen Edmunds, which has become my favorite pair of shoes ever, needed a little attention so I repeated the same easy process and shipped my shoes to Wisconsin free of charge taking advantage of a 10% discount. When I received the shoes back, there was an letter from Paul Grangaard, president and CEO of the shoe company. The letter contains a Paul Harvey-like ‘rest of the story’ that explains the origins of the discount offer. The company wanted to do something for its customers who in 2009 where feeling the impact of the recession purchasing fewer newer shoes – so Allen Edmunds came up with the idea to offer a discount. The company recrafted 8,000 pairs of shoes stressing not only the local post office but also their cobblers who needed all of six weeks to get caught up. The company repeated the offer in 2010, but forecasted lower demand due to an improving economy and perhaps due also to the 8,000 pairs of shoes updated in 2009. But in the same period of time, Allen Edmunds received 16,000 pair of shoes on the way to recrafting a total of 60,000 pair in 2010!

In addition to the CEO’s recrafting note, I also received a $35 coupon good toward the purchase of a new pair of shoes and a free pair of athletic socks. What a deal!

Over the past year I have written about and spoken of solving complex problems – those problems that, by nature, produce cascading effects that often are hard to predict. This shoe story is a bit different than some themes on which I have mused, but for the executives of Allen Edmunds, who certainly felt the impact of a sour economy, boosting revenue when customers were not keen on spending $300 for a new pair of shoes was a complex problem. But the genius behind the offer turned out not so much that demand outstripped the forecast or that customer loyalty deepened. Rather, I think the genius behind the offer, albeit unintended, is the expansion of the cobbler team (jobs) and the recrafting lessons learned from restoring tens-of-thousands of pairs of shoes over the past three years.

So I’ll close with a couple of thoughts.

First, learning and development around leadership and character takes time (see Perseverance - The Reading Glasses Principle, published 29 August 2010) – not unlike the time it takes to wear out a high quality pair of shoes. For a company that sells a product that is expensive and can last for upwards of twenty years with care and regular maintenance, customer loyalty is paramount to long-term growth and learning and development with that in mind must match the same long-term horizon. Do you have a plan to sustain your personal development? Should it include a major event – an offsite session (like sending your shoes for recrafting) – in order to infuse new ideas, thinking and enthusiasm into your leadership?

Second, I don’t know Paul Grangaard or his executive team, but I suspect that the company is well-led based on how they treat their customers. Allen Edmunds finds ways to stay connect with its customers whether it is promoting a recrafting service in a down economy or publishing a CEO blog accessible from the company’s homepage. But the indicator that I appreciate the most is the by-name recognition of John Bittner, the company’s master shoemaker, made by Mr. Grangaard when he wrote about the expansion of Bittner’s recrafting team. It reminded me of Jim Collins’ “window and mirror” research from his book, Good to Great. In that book, Collins noted that the most effective leaders have a knack for looking out the window to recognize success in others, but looked in the mirror to place responsibility on them when success eluded a plan.

Lastly, we are entering June – a month marked by high school graduation and that contains Father’s Day. If you are thinking of a unique gift that will be enjoyed for years to come, why not help a young man buy a his first pair of Allen Edmunds shoes or a dad something that will last for many more Father’s Days?

RVA

PS – I have my eye on a new pair of Allen Edmunds. I think this pair will be the Winnetka…

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

The Weld Principle - When a break is properly repaired, the scar makes you stronger.

By Rick Van Arnam

Northfield, Vermont

In the summer of 1976, my parents did something cool to our house. They started an addition large enough for an indoor swimming pool. Back then, a house with a swimming pool was as cool as any flat screen, home theater set-up available today and the fact that it was indoors made it an over-the-top project. I have fond memories of our pool, which was really a lengthy do-it-yourself project that was the vision of my dad, an architect. One early memory of the construction involves an excavator used to both build a road to the site and to dig the actual hole that would become the pool. In maneuvering the excavator in a tight spot, Fred the operator snapped the front-left steering rod making the tire swing freely and out of control. The excavator was inoperable. At that point, Fred hopped down off the seat and colorfully announced the obvious and optimistically declared that it could be repaired and made better than new. And that is exactly what he did. He brought in his welding torches on the same road that he had made and quickly repaired the break. It was the first time that I had ever heard that steel repaired by a weld is stronger at the weld than before the break. Welding can be a pretty sophisticated science, but it is true that if done correctly, a weld can be stronger due to the intense heat required in the process.

The idea that something can be made stronger through a healing or fixing process provides hope and that may explain why so many people choose to persevere through adversity and tough situations. Fred’s welding repair is the inspiration for the fifth of my eleven character principles titled, The Weld Principle, and states that, “When a break is properly repaired, the scar makes you stronger.” More important than the principle is the accompanying question, “How will you learn from mistakes or failure?”

Especially in the world of sports, who doesn’t like a good comeback story? Each of the major sports actually recognizes a Comeback Player of the Year with an award. It doesn’t really matter why a player was eligible for consideration – most fans respect and often pull for, a player who has undergone a major challenge, whether self-induced or not, and returns to excel.

This week, flying under and behind the radar of College Basketball’s Final Four, is College Hockey’s Frozen Four. Like the personal interest stories that emanated from basketball’s March Madness, there are stories associated with the hockey’s Frozen Four. The Fighting Irish may have a difficult time reaching College Football’s BCS, but the hockey program is strong and their fans hope that Notre Dame will reach the finals as they did in 2008, and win, for the first time ever. For fans who love to cheer against Notre Dame, they can hop on the University of Minnesota-Duluth’s bandwagon. The Bulldogs, of such famed alumni as Mark Pavelich (1980 Olympian) and Hockey Hall of Famer, Brett Hull, will also be looking to secure their first-ever national championship. On the other side of the semi-final bracket are Michigan and North Dakota. No school has won more national championships than Michigan and combined they have appeared in forty-three Frozen Four tournaments.

But The Weld Principle storyline that comes out of the Frozen Four this year rests with North Dakota senior Matt Frattin, who is a finalist for the Hobey Baker Award – college hockey’s premier award recognizing the year’s top player. A 2007 draft pick of the NHL’s Toronto Maple Leafs, he had been dismissed from the team by head coach Dave Hakstol prior to the start of the 2009 season after separate incidents resulting in two arrests. Skeptics will say that the coach’s decision in early 2010 to re-instate Matt Frattin was more about winning than anything else. Comeback enthusiasts, though, want to believe that Frattin learned from his mistakes and has matured his character in the process of becoming a dominant college hockey player as a senior – a year in which he led the nation with 36 goals and developed into a NHL-ready player. Either way, there is plenty to learn for all of us who face a point at which we have scratched, dented or broken our character.

First, coach Dave Hakstol cracked the door for Frattin’s re-instatement when he said in dismissing the player that, “But we also care about Matt Frattin and would like to put him in position to be able to lead a healthy lifestyle and resume his hockey career.”1 Hakstol went on to say, “Frattin’s status with the team might be revisited.”2 I have written before that the real need for purposeful character development is to close a gap that exists between skill, which can be developed in people younger and younger, and the maturity of their character, which takes much longer. Providing a chance to re-visit a player’s status provides hope and some mild encouragement without the promise of anything.

Second, Matt Frattin appears to have taken the more difficult road to the Frozen Four. A few of college hockey’s top underclassmen opt to leave school early for the pros. Frattin likely could have done just that. Had he done so, our last memory of him in the college ranks would have been his dismissal press release, not his appearance at the Frozen Four. There were conditions Frattin had to meet in order to be considered for reinstatement which points to the greatest learning related to The Weld Principle. When something in our character breaks, we need to have a plan – and follow it. Common components of any plan would include accepting responsibility and any punishment, seeking professional help for an area that may be at the core of the problem, avoiding all circumstances that could slow repair or create more damage, and establishing accountability by sharing the plan with a person or an organization that has genuine interest.

Why do fans enjoy comeback stories so much? I’m not sure there is a scientific answer to that question. But I think it has to do with the most important character trait of all – humility. Humility can grow out of humiliation and I think in most cases, an athlete who recovers from a character break, feels humiliated when he reads his name in the paper portrayed in a poor light. And facing the media at the Frozen Four and the Hobey Baker Award ceremony, you can bet that Matt Frattin will face at least as many questions about his past as he will face about his future. I’m hoping that under that stress, Matt Frattin will show us signs of being stronger reminded by the scars of his past – that is The Weld Principle.

RVA

Credits

1 Junior Forward Matt Frattin Dismissed From Men’s Hockey Team, FightingSioux.com, August 19, 2009

2 Ibid

UMD, Notre Dame hope to join NCAA elite, by Bob Snow – NHL.com Correspondent, March 30, 2011, NHL.Com

CHN Player of the Year: Matt Frattin, by CHN Staff Report, College Hockey News, www.collegehockeynews.com, April 1, 2011